Welcome to The Pizza Shop Of Etters
The Pizza Shop of Etters is a beloved gem located at 940 Old Trail Rd, Goldsboro, PA. Renowned for its consistently fresh and flavorful pizzas, it’s become a staple for locals seeking quality takeout. Customers rave about the homemade flavors, from their BBQ chicken pizza to unique specialty pies. Beyond the delicious food, the restaurant embodies exceptional customer service, often making thoughtful gestures like treating pets during orders. The welcoming atmosphere and dedication to community involvement shine through, making it more than just a pizza shop—it’s a cherished gathering place for families and friends. Highly recommended!
The Pizza Shop Of Etters: Reviews & Ratings
The Pizza Shop of Etters is hands-down our go-to for takeout—and has been for years! Whether it's a birthday party, a family get-together, or just a night we’re craving great food, we never hesitate to call them. Their pizza and other menu items are always fresh and consistently delicious (bbq chicken pizza is my fav). But what truly sets them apart is their incredible customer service and the thoughtful little things—like bringing a treat for our dog with each order. That small gesture might seem simple, but it means so much to us. It shows they care not just about making good food, but about their customers and community, too. It’s that kind of personal touch that keeps us coming back again and again. Thank you, Pizza Shop of Etters, for always going the extra mile! Highly recommend!
Great Local spot! The pizza is always hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. You can tell they care about quality from the dough to the sauce, everything tastes homemade. Staff is friendly and service is quick whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. Definitely one of the best pizza places. Highly Recommended!
Best delivery driver I’ve ever met! Didn’t get his name but he’s tall lol. Food came really hot and fast! He was really nice to my kids and joked around with them.
The Pizza Shop of Etters not only serves delicious pizza, they also serve stellar community partnership. Thanks to their support our concessions proudly had Pizza Shop of Etters pizza on the menu for every home game the entire season. (And a lot of happy customers!) On behalf of the Board of Directors of the West Shore Youth Lacrosse Club we want to say thank you for your commitment to our club. You’re an asset to our community!
Brief qualifying statement about myself: I've been working in a kitchen for ten years and makings pizzas for five. For a first taste I ordered my favorite pie - bacon, pineapple and jalapenos. I immediately noticed the mozzarella had a great flavor and wasn't exceptionally greasy like so many other pizza shops. The toppings were provided generously and distributed correctly. Warm, welcoming atmosphere as I waited for my food. Thanks again guys
I moved to York Haven area in August and searched for a couple months for a good place to eat. I found this place through shopping at the warehouse. This place is hands down the BEST!!! Food is amazing, service is great, and always served with a smile and maybe a Seinfeld reference. Lol.. prices are good especially for the amount of food you get, i even share with coworkers sometime. Haha
I've decided, I will not be returning as a customer to this shop, but I would love to support the staff I enjoyed as a customer.. Shout out to Ryan and Eric for their dedication to The Pizza Shop of Etters The way they carve time out of their busy lives by coming in early and staying later or working in a 120 degree shop with no AC to bring you the wonderful service and food that Mike D simply delivers is commendable to say the absolute least about the skill and dedication they bring to the shop. These raving reviews simply WOULD NOT be a thing without Ryan and Eric. The cooks that hear the damn timer in their sleep. Thank you again, Ryan, for 3 years of the best food and service!
Super friendly people. Great food! I'm staying at local hotel for the week and had these guys deliver. They delivered right to my room and I can't say enough how nice, friendly and accommodating these guys are. Delivery guy was a great guy and lady who took my order over the phone was very friendly as well. My sub and fries were great! These are the kind of people that make me want to do business with them. Thank you!!
Location
-
940 Old Trail Rd, Goldsboro, PA 17319, United States Hotline: +1 717-938-2217
Welcome to The Pizza Shop Of Etters, where flavor and community come together on every slice. Located at 940 Old Trail Rd, Goldsboro, PA 17319, this local gem has captivated the hearts and taste buds of residents for years, earning the esteemed title of a go-to spot for takeout. With a reputation for delicious, fresh ingredients and an unwavering commitment to quality, this establishment has become a beloved fixture in the neighborhood.
One of the standout features of The Pizza Shop Of Etters is its mouthwatering menu, which consistently delivers homemade taste that elevates pizza to an art form. Customers rave about the BBQ chicken pizza, a true fan favorite, but the joy doesn’t stop there. From a well-balanced, flavorful crust to perfectly layered toppings, each bite reflects their passion for crafting exceptional dishes. As Bree Thomas puts it, the thoughtful touches, like a complimentary treat for your furry friends with each order, showcase how much they care about their customers and the community.
Speed and friendliness are also a hallmark of The Pizza Shop Of Etters experience. According to Katie Reyes, the delivery drivers not only bring your piping hot food swiftly but do so with a smile and a sense of humor, making the service as delightful as the food itself. Meanwhile, David O'Brien highlights the attentive staff and the quick service whether dining in or taking out, which is essential in today’s fast-paced world.
The Pizza Shop Of Etters isn’t just about great food; it’s about forging connections with the community. Their support of local organizations, like the West Shore Youth Lacrosse Club, reinforces their role as a valuable community partner. Brandy Burnham's heartfelt gratitude illustrates how deeply residents appreciate their commitment to local initiatives. Chris Nauss, a seasoned kitchen worker, attests to their quality, noting the superior taste of their mozzarella and generous toppings that exemplify their dedication to culinary excellence.
In a world filled with choices, The Pizza Shop Of Etters stands out as more than just a pizza place; it is a symbol of community spirit and culinary passion. The combination of expertly crafted cuisine, stellar customer service, and a welcoming atmosphere make it a top choice. So why not indulge in their offerings and experience the warmth and flavor that keeps everyone coming back for more? Your taste buds—and your community—will thank you.
For those ready to give it a try, you can reach them at +1 717-938-2217. Grab a slice and join the community celebration of good food at The Pizza Shop Of Etters!